Anti Fraud Measures reduce number of Car Crash claims in Cork

22 August 2018
By Elaine Murphy

The Motor Insurers’ Bureau of Ireland (MIBI) believes the strategy they introduced for fighting fraud is impacting on the market, after recording a 1 percent drop in claims involving uninsured or untraced vehicles in Cork during the first 7 months of 2018.  Over the January to July period, the MIBI received a total of 129 claims from Cork, a drop of 1 from the 130 Cork claims they had received by the end of July 2017.

File photo of Cork City Hall – a landmark building in Cork. 
Picture: Jim Coughlan.

The MIBI is a non-profit organisation established to provide compensation to victims of accidents involving uninsured or untraced vehicles.

Last year the MIBI introduced a comprehensive plan to make it as difficult as possible for fraudulent claims to succeed.  This included measures to put the full weight of the MIBI’s internal and external resources behind investigating suspicious claims, working hand in hand with the Gardaí to look into these cases as well as legally contesting such claims and bringing them to trial to be scrutinised by the full power of the courts.

The MIBI also recorded a national drop in figures during the first seven months of the year, with the number of claims throughout the country decreasing by 144, marking an 8 percent decline in claims when compared to the previous year.

In the first 7 months of the year, the MIBI has received fewer claims from 18 of the 26 counties.  The largest drop in number of claims came from Louth with 34 fewer received by the end of July, followed by Dublin (drop of 33) and Kildare (drop of 17).  The largest percentage drop was in Roscommon which had a 41% reduction, followed by Louth (-40%), Leitrim (-38%) and Cavan (-34%).

Of the eight counties which recorded an increase in claims, the largest was in Laois, which recorded 8 additional claims in comparison with 2017.

Speaking about the figures, Chief Executive of the MIBI, David Fitzgerald said, “It is positive to see that the number of claims nationally is starting to reduce. Admittedly these figures represent only a snapshot in time and some of the county by county numbers, such as the Cork figures, are too small to draw any significant conclusions from.  However, considering these statistics cover over half a year’s worth of data, they are a useful barometer of the general MIBI claims’ environment and this shows a noteworthy drop in the total number of claims.

“Taking a more detailed look at the claims received, we do believe a significant portion of this decrease is because of the increased scrutiny we are placing on fraudulent claims.  According to our handlers, since we adopted our ‘Fighting Fraud’ strategy, which involves a zero tolerance approach to fraud, there has been a noticeable decrease in the number of claims where the evidence does not back up the case being made.

“Fraudsters are starting to get the message that if they want to make a fictional claim to the MIBI then they will have to be prepared to have that claim put through microscopic examination.  Any such claims from Cork or any other part of the country will be thoroughly investigated by the MIBI working in co-operation with the Gardaí. If the evidence still doesn’t add up, they will be brought before the courts.  The days of easy settlements for nonsense claims are definitely over.

“The MIBI would like to make it clear that those who have a real claim have nothing to worry about.  The MIBI has always been a pro-victims organisation and when the claim is real and justified we support the claimant.  However, protecting victims also means reducing fraud as much as possible.

“We want to ensure that malicious individuals who make the roads more dangerous by staging fake accidents find it harder and harder to succeed.  That is in the interests of everyone using the roads in Cork or anywhere in Ireland and it is a strategy we are committed to pressing in the months and years to come,” Mr. Fitzgerald concluded.

County by County Breakdown

County Jan – July 2018 Claims Jan – July 2017 Claims Increase/ Decrease Percentage increase/ decrease
Carlow 19 17 2 12%
Cavan 25 38 -13 -34%
Clare 22 26 -4 -15%
Cork 129 130 -1 -1%
Donegal 52 46 6 13%
Dublin 672 705 -33 -5%
Galway 70 80 -10 -13%
Kerry 34 42 -8 -19%
Kildare 67 84 -17 -20%
Kilkenny 10 6 4 67%
Laois 27 19 8 42%
Leitrim 5 8 -3 -38%
Limerick 99 94 5 5%
Longford 14 18 -4 -22%
Louth 52 86 -34 -40%
Mayo 19 28 -9 -32%
Meath 65 63 2 3%
Monaghan 22 25 -3 -12%
Offaly 17 15 2 13%
Roscommon 10 17 -7 -41%
Sligo 18 15 3 20%
Tipperary 32 34 -2 -6%
Waterford 25 32 -7 -22%
Westmeath 22 25 -3 -12%
Wexford 23 34 -11 -32%
Wicklow 22 29 -7 -24%
Total 1,572 1,716 -144 -8%

About The Motor Insurers Bureau of Ireland (MIBI)

The MIBI was established in 1955 by an Agreement between the Government and the companies underwriting motor insurance in Ireland for the purpose of compensating victims of road traffic accidents caused by uninsured and unidentified vehicles. All insurers underwriting motor insurance in Ireland are required to be members of the MIBI. The MIBI is funded entirely by motor insurance companies operating in Ireland and ultimately by premiums paid by all insured motorists.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login